117 research outputs found
An Incentive-Based Framework for Analyzing the Alignment of Institutional Interventions in the Public Primary Healthcare Sector: The Portuguese Case
Over the years, the Portuguese National Health Service has undergone several reforms to
face the challenges posed by internal and external factors on the access to and quality of its health
services. One of its most recent reforms addressed the primary healthcare sector, where understanding the incentives behind the actors of the inherent institutional interventions and how they are
aligned with the governing health policies is paramount for reformative success. With the purpose of
acknowledging the alignment of the primary healthcare sectorâs institutional interventions from an
incentive-based perspective, we propose a framework resting on a SWOT (Strengths, Weaknesses,
Opportunities, and Threats) analysis, which was built in cooperation with a panel of decision-making
actors from the Portuguese Ministry of Health. In the end, we derive possible policy implications and
strategies. This holistic approach highlighted the positive impact of the primary healthcare reform in
the upgrade of physical resources and human capital but stressed the geosocial asymmetries and the
lack of intra- and inter-sectorial coordination. The proposed framework serves also as a guideline for
future primary healthcare reforms, both national- and internationally.info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersio
A step forward on order-α robust nonparametric method: inclusion of weight restrictions, convexity and non-variable returns to scale
Partial frontiers have been recently developed in order to overcome several
drawbacks of the traditional nonparametric techniques. These robust frontier (order-a
and order-m) methods avoid the curse of dimensionality, are less sensitive to outliers
and extreme data and may include direct environmental information in the model.
Nonetheless, the disadvantages of these partial frontier-based methods according to
the formulation proposed in the literature are that they do not allow weight restrictions
or non-variable returns to scale technology. The procedure here proposed is an
extension of the traditional order-a method, allowing the estimation of an empirical
convex a-level, assuming also some additional constraints, such as the virtual weight
restrictions and non-variable returns to scale. In the particular case of nonconvex
attainable sets, unrestricted formulations and variable returns to scale assumption, the
proposed procedure returns the same results as the standard order-ainfo:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersio
A Critical Analysis of Decentralizing the Portuguese Public Healthcare Provision Services
The Portuguese health system has a universal, public, general National Health Service (NHS), tending towards free healthcare access. Created in 1979, this delivery model developed from the integration and complementarity between the different response levels (primary, hospital, continuing, and palliative care). However, over the last 40 years, the initially centralized system underwent a decentralization process with the creation of Regional Health Administrations in the five mainland administrative regions. Since then, the entire NHS has settled around this new organization. The most recent step started in 2018 with the decentralization of primary healthcare skills to 190 municipalities. This paper presents the various critical issues involved in the latest gradual decentralization process in health, intending to bring services closer to the citizens, and to be more focused on their needs. The article identifies and discusses the implications of this experience based on the steps foreseen in the already-published legal texts.info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersio
Operational efficiency vs clinical safety, care appropriateness, timeliness, and access to health care
Health care systems face resource scarcity that may jeopardise their financial sustainability as well as the quality of delivered health care. In view of that, the association between technical efficiency, access, and quality of services should be investigated, despite some past attempts that led to mixed, unclear, and perhaps biased results. We use a dataset composed of financial resources, hospital services, appropriateness and timeliness of care, patientsâ clinical safety, access to health care services, demographics, and epidemiology variables to study the aforementioned link regarding the Portuguese public hospitals (operating between 2013 and 2016). Quality and access data are aggregated into three main composite indicators, through Grey Relational Analysis (GRA). Bias- and environmentally corrected efficiency scores are estimated via bootstrap-based directional Data Envelopment Analysis. A double bootstrap algorithm is employed, using GRA-based quality indicators as predictors of technical efficiency. Evidence suggests that (1) Portuguese public hospitals exhibit low performance in terms of quality, while the different indicators present considerable correlation among them and with hospital size and patientsâ complexity characteristics; (2) patientsâ clinical safety, appropriateness and timeliness, as well as access to health care services are consistent and significant predictors of technical efficiency; and (3) the association between efficiency, quality, and access depends on the interaction between appropriateness, timeliness, and access. Therefore, quality and access can be improved with no efficiency sacrifice and vice versa.info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersio
Investment in drinking water and sanitation infrastructure and its impact on waterborne diseases dissemination: The Brazilian case
Investment in sanitation and drinking water infrastructure is essential for universal access to these services in developing countries. Universal coverage of water and sanitation services (WSS) can prevent the dissemination of
waterborne diseases and mitigate their adverse effects. These diseases are responsible for many deaths worldwide, especially among the disadvantaged population and children. A causal effect can be established between
WSS investment and hospital admissions due to waterborne diseases. Therefore, we considered an innovative
network-DEA approach that models the link between serially connected subsystems (upstream investment
and downstream hospitalizations). This approach allowed us: to measure the efficiency of both subsystems; estimate the amount of (efficient) investment necessary to universalize the access to proper WSS infrastructure;
and mitigate hospital admissions due to waterborne diseases. We used the Brazil case study to test our model.
On average, Brazilian states could increase the number of people not requiring hospitalizations due to waterborne diseases by 157 thousand per R100 million
invested in drinking water. Our results suggest that relatively small (efficient) investment in those two infrastructure types has a massive impact on hospitalizations. This impact would be more significant than the investment in WSS coverage. Therefore, if safely managed, WSS would cover all citizens, and Brazil would come closer
to developed countries.info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersio
Pay for performance in health care: a new best practice tariff-based tool using a log-linear piecewise frontier function and a dualâprimal approach for unique solutions
Health care systems worldwide have faced a problem of resources scarcity that, in
turn, should be allocated to the health care providers according to the corresponding
population needs. Such an allocation should be as much as effective and efficient as
possible to guarantee the sustainability of those systems. One alternative to reach
that goal is through (prospective) payments due to the providers for their clinical
procedures. The way that such payments are computed is frequently unknown and
arguably far from being optimal. For instance, in Portugal, public hospitals are
clustered based on criteria related to size, consumed resources, and volume of
medical acts, and payments associated with the inpatient services are equal to the
smallest unitary cost within each cluster. First, there is no reason to impose a single
benchmark for each inefficient hospital. Second, this approach disregards dimen sions like quality (and access) and the environment, which are paramount for fair
comparisons and benchmarking exercises. This paper proposes an innovative tool to
achieve best-practices tariff. This tool merges both quality and financial sustain ability concepts, attributing a hospital-specific tariff that can be different from
hospital to hospital. That payment results from the combination of costs related to a
set of potential benchmarks, keeping quality as high as possible and higher than a
user-predefined threshold, and being able to generate considerable cost savings. To
obtain those coefficients we propose and detail a log-linear piecewise frontier
function as well as a dualâprimal approach for unique solutions.info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersio
A critical look at the Portuguese publicâprivate partnerships in healthcare
The preâconceived idea that contracts in a publicâprivate
partnership (PPP) regime, in healthcare or in any other
economic sector, are, as a rule, ruinous and appealing for
only a share of the stakeholders, lacks a solid basis that
confirms it. This idea, outset and nurtured by the media,
has been instigating the distrust of the users who, in turn,
demand a more rigorous and efficient utilisation of public
resources. Being Portugal in the top of countries that
resort to PPPs, it is urgent to inquire if its respective
contracts originated an inefficient and ineffective management of resources. It is precisely this discussion that we
address in this paper, focusing our efforts in the Portuguese healthcare sectorinfo:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersio
Economic Inefficiency Levels of Urban Solid Waste Management Services in Portugal
Key performance indicators (KPI) are widely used tools to evaluate the economic (in)efficiency
of services, including the ones devoted to urban solid waste management. Regulatory exercises
are, then, mostly based on the outputs from KPIs, raising some questions about their validity.
In theory, other more appropriate tools could be used to estimate those efficiency levels. This study
evaluates the economic inefficiency level of urban solid waste management services in Portugal
(2010â2017) through the adoption of partial frontier benchmarking models (order-m) coupled with
weight restrictions. That way, the constructed model can evaluate the performance of those services
under some regulatory and sustainability requirements. Then, estimated efficiency levels and some
common KPIs are compared in order to understand if the latter are sufficient to explain the economic
efficiency. The novelty of this research lies in two main aspects: (a) the utilization of a robust order-α
model coupled with weight restrictions linked to regulatory and sustainability impositions to estimate
efficiency, and (b) the comparison of economic efficiency and some commonly used KPIs, including
waste fractions and recycling rate. Results point towards efficiency distributions that follow Weibull
functions, with the average close to 50%; thus, nearly half of the resources have been well spent
in municipal solid waste management services since 2010 onwards. Nonetheless, in an efficient
system, that average would be close to 100%. Additionally, the considered management related
KPIs do not exhibit any relationship with economic efficiency, which means that their interpretation
and usefulness for regulatory issues are both limited and should be used carefully. In other words,
those KPIs are not good performance drivers and carry no capacity to explain economic (in)efficiency
in urban solid waste management services.info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersio
Quality assessment of the Portuguese public hospitals: A multiple criteria approach
The Portuguese National Health Service (SNS) was created to provide universal, equal, and tendentiously
free care. There are different levels of care (primary, secondary, continued, and palliative) and all of them
should deliver quality care services. Quality in healthcare is assessed according to several criteria, such as
patient safety, care appropriateness or access. However, over the last years political and economic events
have had an impact on the SNS. Hence, structural reforms have occurred, and new healthcare policies
have been implemented, mostly focused on improving efficiency and reducing costs. It associated to di vestment can increment barriers to access, compromise infrastructures and equipment, and, above all,
the serviceâs quality. This work aims to assess quality of the Portuguese public hospitals (secondary care
providers) in this line. To this aim, we adopt a multiple criteria decision aiding approach, applying the
Electre Tri-nC method to build a decision model with intervention of an expert, who acts as the decision maker. Hospitals are assessed and assigned to predefined categories, taking into account the hospitalsâ performances on various criteria. Each criterion is characterized by different subcriteria, resulting
in a complex criteria tree. Thus, to construct a multidimensional scale for each criterion, we propose an
innovative approach using an Electre Tri-based method. The results are analyzed and the robustness of
the model is tested. This workâs findings may have potential application to healthcare policy and hospital
funding in the SNS, in which financial sustainability is a permanent challenge.info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersio
- âŠ